Social Links Search User Login Menu

Sudden Death | Thunder Bay 2019

Does Canada have a two-tiered system of justice?
Troy Media
/ Categories: Ontario, Public Safety

Does Canada have a two-tiered system of justice?

We now have a justice system that favours those with “acceptable political views” while persecuting those with “unacceptable views”

THUNDER  BAY, OTTAWA, ONTARIO  ~~~~~  August 15, 2022 (LSNews)  The FBI raid on the home of former U.S. President Donald Trump has emphasized existing concerns that the United States now has a two-tiered justice system – one for those in power and another for those who aren’t.

But here in Canada, we have a quieter version of that same debate, revealed during the convoy protests.

Brian GiesbrechtA long-standing political discussion within Canada has concerned a so-called “two-tiered health care system” replacing the current socialist model. One side argues that allowing private enterprise to participate in the system would improve it, while supporters of the status quo argue that it would create a “two-tier” system that would hurt the less advantaged. That discussion is playing out in the courts today, particularly with the case brought by Dr. Brian Day.

However, until very recently, there has not been a concern about a two-tiered justice system, where one’s political view determines what kind of justice one will receive. In fact, up until recently, there has been a universal agreement on the principle that the system should treat everyone equally. While it has always been recognized that those with money have better access to lawyers, it has always been taken for granted that a person’s political views would be irrelevant when meting out justice. Simply put, that Justice would be blind to the politics of the day.

That has changed, and the case of Tamara Lich brings worries that we now have a justice system that favours those with “acceptable political views” while persecuting those with “unacceptable views.”

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau explained his “acceptable views” philosophy to Canadians when he was asked why he supported (and even participated in) protests, such as the Black Live Matter (BLM) and the Wet’suwet’en protests, but condemned, and was willing to make illegal, the convoy protest.

He said he supported those with “acceptable views” and condemned those with “unacceptable views.” In his view, he gets to decide which views are “acceptable” and which views are “unacceptable.” In the case of those who supported the convoy protests, those with “unacceptable views,” Trudeau labelled those citizens as “racists” and “misogynists.” His government then treated those protestors in a draconian way never before seen in this country. People had their bank accounts frozen, some were jailed, and some had their trucks and personal property seized.

No other protestors in Canadian history had ever been treated as harshly. For example, the Wet’suwet’en and BLM protests had caused far more damage than the convoy protest, but no one in those protests was charged with committing crimes. It should be remembered that the BLM protests (in which Trudeau actually participated) took the lives of dozens of people and caused billions of dollars in property damage.

The Wet’suwet’en protests shut down the nation’s railway system for weeks, causing major economic damage. Incidental crimes committed during the Wet’suwet’en protests, such as arson and vandalism, could easily have taken lives and certainly disrupted and damaged the economy. (For that matter, the church vandalism and statue toppling caused after the dubious claim of the discovery of 215 residential school students’ bodies in Kamloops last summer has resulted in almost no charges.). Apparently, anyone participating in those protests, even those who committed crimes, passed the Prime Minister’s “acceptable views” test.

But the convoy protestors were treated in an entirely different manner.

Tamara Lich saw every part of the newly created two-tier system play out from the inside of a jail cell, as police, junior justice officials, and others treated her the way a political dissident would be treated in a dictatorship. For doing what thousands of BLM, Wet’suwet’en, and unmarked graves protestors did with impunity, Tamara Lich was jailed and treated in a manner unbefitting a Canadian citizen.

But the out-of-court remarks by Chief Justice Wagner made things much worse. The Chief Justice, who had not denounced protestors in those much more damaging protests, singled out the convoy protestors for censure.

So, people like Tamara Lich now know exactly where they stand with the government in power, and with the Justice system. They are no longer citizens but enemies. They have “unacceptable views.” And people with “unacceptable views” face the prospect of having their views judged by a Chief Justice who has made his views about people like Lich very clear.

Justice is supposed to be blind. Does Canada now have a two-tiered system of Justice?

Brian Giesbrecht is a retired judge and a senior fellow at the Frontier Centre for Public Policy.

#LSN_PublicSafety #LSN_ONNews #LSN_TBay 

Below Please Rate and Share this story 
To help us learn what is important to you

© Troy Media

The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by Lake Superior News / Lake Superior Media.

Troy Media Founded in 2005, Troy Media has grown to become Canada’s largest independent provider of original editorial features, opinions and analysis. Content sourced from Troy Media appears in dozens of newspapers, news sites, blogs and radio reports daily. Annual readership is estimated to be greater than 750 million.


Rate this article:
No rating
5Upvote 2Downvote

Murders Thunder Bay vs other Ontario Cities

Thunder Bay maintained its title as the murder capital of Canada in 2018,  For the third consecutive year - and the fourth time in the last five years

 It has been announced again that Thunder Bay is the Murder Capital of Canada for 2018 in Canada for CMAs with populations between 100,000 to less than 500,000 people

Thunder Bay had the highest rate in that category with 6.38 homicides per 100,000.
Barrie with zero
St. Catharines–Niagara  Region with 0.42


Thunder Bay has the highest Opiod death Rate in Ontario

Path 525 Thunder Bay Drug Injection Site  Lake Superior NewsIn 2018, 44 people died of opioid overdose in Thunder Bay.

It’s made Thunder Bay the highest per capita opioid death rate in Ontario.

The 44 deaths were a 40 per cent increase from 2017, a year in which Thunder Bay also held the highest provincial rate.

Between July 2017 and June 2018, nearly 3,900 naloxone kits were handed out by the Thunder Bay District Health Unit and local pharmacies, 



Thunder Bay is that the homicide rate for 2017 is down from 2016 when it stood at 6.62 per 100,000

Greater Sudbury's murder rate is  remains one of the lowest in Canada. murder rate was 0.61 per 100,000 people

Thunder Bay as the only Legal Injeciton site in Northern Ontario 

Murders by Ward 2019

  • Homicide #1  Leo Chiodo  Westfort Ward 108th Avenue Mission Island 
  • Homicide #2  Tanya Andy  McIntrye Ward Behind Landmark Inn
  • Homicide #3  Claude Justin KISHIQUEB Current River Ward Cumberland Street
  • Homicide #4  Robenson St Jean McIntrye Ward Hilldale and Melbourne
  • Homicide #5  Andrew Ayre McKellar Ward,  Victoria Ave East
  • Homicide #6  Nazareth Andrew KWANDIBENS Current River Ward  Arundel Street

Follow LSN on Twitter

Latest News

Back To Top