Social Links Search User Login Menu
Tools
Close
Close

Weekly Crime Stats

Thunder Bay Rain Tax Exposed

Thunder Bay Rain Tax Exposed

City paid a quarter of a million dollars for a study

 THUNDER BAY, ONTARIO, February 18. 2020  (LSN)  City hall is where transparency goes to die. The proof? City councillors paid consultants almost a quarter of a million dollars for a study and never made the report public.  

It took a Freedom of Information request to pull back the curtain on just what we got for our money.

Formally, the report is called the Thunder Bay Stormwater Financing Study. Many people knew it as the city’s plan to impose a rainfall tax.

         AECOM, the consultants, tried to make the case that imposing a tax was “the right thing to do”.

         “A stormwater user fee is capable of generating a financially sustainable, equitably allocated, fully supportive, an environmentally friendly mechanism for supporting the City’s stormwater program needs.”

        But there were concerns. According to the report, city hall staff concluded the bureaucracy needed to collect the tax was going to simply cost too much.

            More telling, though, is a phrase in the same bullet point in the report: “it is anticipated that a user fee would not be publicly supported at this time”.

        The report recommended a couple of options. But until now they’d not seen the light of day.

         (One was to change the current tax system to create new levies for urban and rural properties based on the services they received from the city. The second was to adopt a user fee for single family homes.)

        But according to the consultants, when they met with city councillors to discuss the options, the politicians told them “not interested”.

        Here’s what the consultants said about that meeting on April 04th last year:

         “Options were then considered against the status quo and the project team engaged in informed discussions with councillors. It was determined that changes in stormwater financing in isolation is not recommended given that these changes may be short term and may not align with the future holistic plan that includes all infrastructure assets.”

        After the meeting on April 04th, there was silence from city hall about the outcome of the study until June.

        That’s when the city engineer overseeing the project issued a memo to council stating the department was shelving the quarter of a million dollar project.

        It repeated the mantra that there was no business case for a rainfall tax because of high start-up and on-going costs of making it work.

        The public information meeting that was supposed to be held once the study was completed was quietly cancelled.

        All of this suggests council simply bowed to administration’s recommendation to drop the idea of a new tax without seeing the report and discussing it with the consultants. That after spending a quarter of a million to get the report. How believable is that?

         Wasn’t it councillors’ job to have debated the pros and cons of a new tax? Shouldn’t the public have been consulted once the study was completed?

        The public deserved to hear the debate about this contentious tax. It was an issue in the election campaign the year before. And with the decision to shelve the report, all the concern expressed by council and administration about the need to prepare the city’s infrastructure for climate change simply disappeared.

        Just as disturbing: if the cost of implementing the new tax was the deal-breaker, this quarter of a million dollar study wasn’t even needed. Anyone could have figured out costs of the bureaucracy required on the back of an envelope. The numbers involved are publicly available from other cities that imposed the new tax.

 

        Instead, it’s clear from the report that city hall wanted the consultants to sell the public on the idea of this new tax, to do all the heavy political lifting. It didn’t work. The study was quietly shelved with no public debate.

        But we still got the bill.

By Shane Judge
Retired CBC radio reporter and mayoralty candidate

Disclaimer
The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by Lake Superior News / Lake Superior Media.

 

 

Print

Latest Public Safety News

Female Charged with Trafficking 31 March 2020

Female Charged with Trafficking

Sault Ste. Marie Police Service

SAULT STE. MARIE, ONTARIO  ~  March 31, 2020  (LSN)  On March 28, 2020 officers with Patrol Services and Investigation Services arrested 51-year-old Line Duguay for possession of a controlled substance for the purpose of trafficking.

At 12:30 p.m. on March 28, 2020 officers observed a vehicle traveling at walking speed on Farwell Terrace. Upon approaching the vehicle, officers observed the accused to be unresponsive. The officer was able to get her attention after knocking on the driver side window.

#LSN_Crime

CBP to Postpone NEXUS Enrollment Workshop 31 March 2020

CBP to Postpone NEXUS Enrollment Workshop

in Grand Portage

GRAND PORTAGE, MINNESOTA  March 31, 2020  (LSN)  — U.S. Customs and Border Protection will temporarily suspend operations at Trusted Traveler Program enrollment centers nationwide from March 19 until at least May 1, 2020. CBP is taking this precautionary measure to minimize the exposure of CBP personnel and the public to the novel coronavirus (COVID-19). 

#LSN_PublicSafety

Crime Stats March 23 to March 30, 2020 30 March 2020

Crime Stats March 23 to March 30, 2020

Thunder Bay 159 ~ Greater Sudbury 14

THUNDER BAY, SUDBURY, ONTARIO  March 30, 2020  (LSN) Crime Stats  March 23rd to March 30nd Thunder  Bay 159 Incidents vs 14 Incidents for Great Sudbury which as a larger population and does not have an Injections Site.

#LSN_Crime   #LSN_TBay   #LSN_TBPS   #LSN_GSPS

A Filing Extension and New Rules for Service of Tax Petitions 30 March 2020

A Filing Extension and New Rules for Service of Tax Petitions

Cook County Under COVID-19

COOK COUNTY, MINNESOTA ~ March 30, 2020  (LSN) On Saturday, March 28, Governor Walz signed legislation extending the time for filing property tax petitions for contesting 2019 value or classification to May 30, 2020.

In another move to aid in following social distancing rules recommended by public health experts, Cook County will waive personal service of property tax petitions contesting 2019 value or classification so long as property owners meet certain conditions.

#LSN_Health

Fraudulent Public Health Inspector Activity 28 March 2020

Fraudulent Public Health Inspector Activity

Sault Ste. Marie Police Service

SAULT STE. MARIE, ONTARIO  ~  March 28, 2020  (LSN)  Recently, Algoma Public Health (APH) notified the Sault Ste. Marie Police Service about fraudulent activity where individuals are posing as Public Health Inspectors from APH.

On at least two occasions local restaurants have received calls from someone claiming to be a Public Health Inspector offering to inspect the restaurant for a fee. Neither of the potential victims accepted the offer and notified APH.

#LSN_PublicSafety 

“Stay at Home” Is Not A Recommendation 28 March 2020

“Stay at Home” Is Not A Recommendation

By: Molly Hicken, Cook County Attorney

COOK COUNTY, MINNESOTA ~ March 28, 2020  (LSN) Beginning at 11:59 p.m. on Friday, March 27, all those living in Minnesota are ordered by the governor to "stay at home."   The Executive Order signed March 25 is justified by Governor Walz's emergency powers under the COVID-19 state of emergency and is consistent with federal guidelines limiting gatherings of more than 10 people. "Limiting activities to only those which are most essential and practicing social distancing at all times are vital tools required to mitigate the community spread of COVID-19 in Minnesota and Nationwide," the Order asserts.

#LSN_Health

Message Chief Paul Pedersen regarding COVID-19 27 March 2020

Message Chief Paul Pedersen regarding COVID-19

Greater Sudbury Police Service

SUDBURY, ONTARIO  ~~  March 27, 2020  (LSN)  Do your part - stay apart. We go to work for you, stay at home for us. Please follow emergency orders and take warnings from health experts seriously. If you don’t, you not only put your own health at risk, but the health of our Officers, other essential workers and your fellow community members at risk.

#LSN_GSPS

Crime Prevention Tips For Businesses 26 March 2020

Crime Prevention Tips For Businesses

Sault Ste. Marie Police Service

SAULT STE. MARIE, ONTARIO  March 26, 2020  (LSN)  The closure of non-essential businesses in Ontario to address the spread of COVID-19 may cause business owners to worry about the safety of their business and property.

We’ve put together a list of tips for business owners that may help prevent crime to their business and property.

#LSN_PublicSafety  #LSN_SSMPS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Cook County Stay At Home Order 26 March 2020

Cook County Stay At Home Order

COVID-19 Cook County Sheriff Pat Eliasen

COOK COUNTY, MINNESOTA  ~  March 26, 2020  (LSN)  I have been getting many questions about this order since the Governor spoke it yesterday and I wanted to clarify what it looks like from the law enforcement side. People can still travel, as the order defines:

Minnesotans may leave their residences only to perform any of the following activities, and while doing so, they should practice social distancing:

#LSN_CookCounty  #LSN_PublicSafety  #LSN_Health

Elvis Collander, arrested amid child pornography investigation 25 March 2020

Elvis Collander, arrested amid child pornography investigation

Thunder Bay Police Service’s Cyber Crimes Unit

THUNDER BAY, ONTARIO March 25, 2020 - 15:50  (LSN)  Police Media Release States: Members of the Thunder Bay Police Service’s Cyber Crimes Unit began an investigation into alleged online activity involving suspected images of child pornography on March 16, 2020.

Police learned the images were uploaded by a local Internet user. As a result of their ongoing investigation, police were able to identify a 24-year-old male suspect.

Police executed a search warrant at a home in the 800 block of Melbourne Road on March 24.

#LSN_Crime #LSN_TBPS #LSN_ONNews

1345678910Last

Follow LSN on Twitter

Latest News

No content

A problem occurred while loading content.

Previous Next
Back To Top