Social Links Search User Login Menu
Tools
Close
Close

Weekly Crime Stats

Don’t be fooled by ShutDownCanada

Don’t be fooled by ShutDownCanada

misleading claims from dishonest activists

CALGARY, ALBERTA,   - February 21, 2020  (LSN) ——  On Tuesday, while activists reportedly tried to “arrest” Premier John Horgan at his house in British Columbia, Prime Minister Trudeau spoke to the House of Commons, stressing the need for “patience” as rail blockades continue to prevent freight and passenger across Canada.

Indeed, the #ShutDownCanada movement is in full swing in B.C. and across the country, with rail blockades, road closures and protests causing mass disruption and frustration. All because of the proposed Coastal GasLink pipeline through the traditional territory of the Wet’suwet’en First Nations people in B.C.

There’s been a lot said and written over the past week. But here’s what you need to know about this dispute.

According to the 1997 the Supreme Court of Canada Delgamuukw decision, the Wet’suwet’en have aboriginal title to an as-yet-undefined area of B.C. Aboriginal title is a form of ownership, but it’s not absolute. The same Supreme Court decision that recognized aboriginal title also elaborated the doctrine of infringement, which allows government to make use of title land for the public good.

This is one of those cases. The Coastal GasLink pipeline cannot be built without crossing Wet’suwet’en traditional territory. It will carry natural gas from B.C. fields to Kitimat, a municipality in the North Coast region of the province, where it will be liquified and exported to Asian markets. It’s an enormous project that will create profit for investors, revenue for governments (including First Nation governments) and jobs for workers, many of whom will be First Nations people. It will also reduce carbon emissions in the world at large because it will replace coal now burned for power generation in countries such as Japan, China and Korea.

The protestors talk about Wet’suwet’en sovereignty and Wet’suwet’en law, but don’t be misled. Canadian courts have consistently upheld Canadian sovereignty, which means that Parliament and the B.C. legislature have the right make law for the Wet’suwet’en. Traditional Wet’suwet’en laws are enforceable only if explicitly adopted through federal or B.C. legislation, depending on the subject matter. That has not happened. So traditional Wet’suwet’en law cannot be used to block pipeline construction.

In fact, Coastal GasLink passes through the traditional territories of 20 First Nations. The elected band councils of all these First Nations (including the Wet’suwet’en) signed agreements in support of the pipeline because of the substantial benefits they will receive—cash payments from the B.C. government and TC Energy, a natural gas company, not to mention jobs and job-training and contract set-asides for work on the pipeline.

These First Nations are small, poor and remote. They don’t have many economic opportunities. The average income of their members is about half the provincial average. Coastal GasLink is their best—perhaps only—way out of poverty. That’s why their elected governments have endorsed the pipeline.

So where’s the opposition coming from? A faction of the Wet’suwet’en, the hereditary chiefs who claim that only they—not the elected band council—can give consent to the pipeline. Again, don’t be misled. There is no basis in the Canadian Constitution, legislation or judicial decisions for this claim.

Many of the protestors swarming the B.C. legislature or blocking highways and railways across the country are not members of the Wet’suwet’en Nation or any other First Nation. They are the usual crowd of environmentalists and anti-capitalists. For many, their goal is to destroy the market economy that’s created so much prosperity and the democratic government that protects our freedoms. They want a government of activists, where they will call the shots. Their hashtag says it all—#ShutDownCanada.

Don’t be fooled. This isn’t a genuine movement for social justice. These are outsiders exploiting a division within one First Nation in the hope of creating chaos on the ground.

Canada is a free country. If the protestors stay within legal limits, let them speak. If they break the law by obstructing buildings, roads and railways, let the police do their job of re-establishing the civil order on which we all depend.

Author:

Tom Flanagan

Professor Emeritus of Political Science and Distinguished Fellow, School of Public Policy, University of Calgary

-30-


 

 

 

Fraser Institure  Lake Superior NewsThe Fraser Institute
 

https://www.fraserinstitute.org

 

Disclaimer
The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by Lake Superior News / Lake Superior Media.

 

Print

Latest Public Safety News

Update Kareem ZEDAN Captured 2 April 2020

Update Kareem ZEDAN Captured

Pickering murder Release in Error Kareem ZEDAN

THUNDER BAY, ONTARIO  ~  April 2, 2020 - 11:15 (LSN) Police Media Release States: The Thunder Bay Police Service is seeking public assistance in locating a homicide suspect who is now unlawfully at large.

Kareem ZEDAN, 22, of Pickering, Ont., was arrested in Thunder Bay on March 24 and is charged for two counts of First-Degree Murder. The charges are from a double-homicide in the City of Brantford.

OPP Report SECOND DEGREE MURDER CHARGE LAID IN SCHREIBER 2 April 2020

OPP Report SECOND DEGREE MURDER CHARGE LAID IN SCHREIBER

After a 14 year homicide investigation

SCHREIBER, ONTARIO  ~  April 2, 2020  (LSN)  After a 14 year homicide investigation, a Schreiber resident has been arrested and charged with murder.

The investigation began on November 29, 2006, at 2:34 p.m. when members of the Schreiber Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) Detachment were called to investigate the suspicious death of Jeanine St. JEAN at her Quebec Street residence in the Town of Schreiber.

#LSN_Crime

Gathering at Local Schools 1 April 2020

Gathering at Local Schools

Sault Ste. Marie Police Service all schools, parks and playgrounds are closed.

SAULT STE. MARIE, ONTARIO  ~  April 1, 2020  (LSN)  The Sault Ste. Marie Police Service has recently received reports of young people gathering at local schools.

Due to the state of Emergency in Ontario, all schools, parks and playgrounds in our community are closed.

#LSN_Crime

Female Charged with Trafficking 31 March 2020

Female Charged with Trafficking

Sault Ste. Marie Police Service

SAULT STE. MARIE, ONTARIO  ~  March 31, 2020  (LSN)  On March 28, 2020 officers with Patrol Services and Investigation Services arrested 51-year-old Line Duguay for possession of a controlled substance for the purpose of trafficking.

At 12:30 p.m. on March 28, 2020 officers observed a vehicle traveling at walking speed on Farwell Terrace. Upon approaching the vehicle, officers observed the accused to be unresponsive. The officer was able to get her attention after knocking on the driver side window.

#LSN_Crime

CBP to Postpone NEXUS Enrollment Workshop 31 March 2020

CBP to Postpone NEXUS Enrollment Workshop

in Grand Portage

GRAND PORTAGE, MINNESOTA  March 31, 2020  (LSN)  — U.S. Customs and Border Protection will temporarily suspend operations at Trusted Traveler Program enrollment centers nationwide from March 19 until at least May 1, 2020. CBP is taking this precautionary measure to minimize the exposure of CBP personnel and the public to the novel coronavirus (COVID-19). 

#LSN_PublicSafety

Crime Stats March 23 to March 30, 2020 30 March 2020

Crime Stats March 23 to March 30, 2020

Thunder Bay 159 ~ Greater Sudbury 14

THUNDER BAY, SUDBURY, ONTARIO  March 30, 2020  (LSN) Crime Stats  March 23rd to March 30nd Thunder  Bay 159 Incidents vs 14 Incidents for Great Sudbury which as a larger population and does not have an Injections Site.

#LSN_Crime   #LSN_TBay   #LSN_TBPS   #LSN_GSPS

A Filing Extension and New Rules for Service of Tax Petitions 30 March 2020

A Filing Extension and New Rules for Service of Tax Petitions

Cook County Under COVID-19

COOK COUNTY, MINNESOTA ~ March 30, 2020  (LSN) On Saturday, March 28, Governor Walz signed legislation extending the time for filing property tax petitions for contesting 2019 value or classification to May 30, 2020.

In another move to aid in following social distancing rules recommended by public health experts, Cook County will waive personal service of property tax petitions contesting 2019 value or classification so long as property owners meet certain conditions.

#LSN_Health

Fraudulent Public Health Inspector Activity 28 March 2020

Fraudulent Public Health Inspector Activity

Sault Ste. Marie Police Service

SAULT STE. MARIE, ONTARIO  ~  March 28, 2020  (LSN)  Recently, Algoma Public Health (APH) notified the Sault Ste. Marie Police Service about fraudulent activity where individuals are posing as Public Health Inspectors from APH.

On at least two occasions local restaurants have received calls from someone claiming to be a Public Health Inspector offering to inspect the restaurant for a fee. Neither of the potential victims accepted the offer and notified APH.

#LSN_PublicSafety 

“Stay at Home” Is Not A Recommendation 28 March 2020

“Stay at Home” Is Not A Recommendation

By: Molly Hicken, Cook County Attorney

COOK COUNTY, MINNESOTA ~ March 28, 2020  (LSN) Beginning at 11:59 p.m. on Friday, March 27, all those living in Minnesota are ordered by the governor to "stay at home."   The Executive Order signed March 25 is justified by Governor Walz's emergency powers under the COVID-19 state of emergency and is consistent with federal guidelines limiting gatherings of more than 10 people. "Limiting activities to only those which are most essential and practicing social distancing at all times are vital tools required to mitigate the community spread of COVID-19 in Minnesota and Nationwide," the Order asserts.

#LSN_Health

Message Chief Paul Pedersen regarding COVID-19 27 March 2020

Message Chief Paul Pedersen regarding COVID-19

Greater Sudbury Police Service

SUDBURY, ONTARIO  ~~  March 27, 2020  (LSN)  Do your part - stay apart. We go to work for you, stay at home for us. Please follow emergency orders and take warnings from health experts seriously. If you don’t, you not only put your own health at risk, but the health of our Officers, other essential workers and your fellow community members at risk.

#LSN_GSPS

1345678910Last

Follow LSN on Twitter

Latest News

Back To Top