In response to the economic crisis caused by the COVID-19 restrictions, the Canadian government has implemented the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB). Eligible people receive $2,000 for a four-week period..." />
Search User Login Menu
Tools
Close
Close

News Headlines

Lake Superior Regional News ~ Northwestern and Northeastern Ontario. Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan. From Kenora, Thunder Bay, Sault Ste Marie and Sudbury, Duluth, Marquette, Houghton, Keweenaw Peninsula, Upper Michigan, Sault Ste Marie, Cook Country, Minnesota. Madison, Wisconsin

Razor Host

News

Universal basic income has been tested and failed

Universal basic income has been tested and failed

Finland acknowledged its two-year experiment a total failure

NORTHERN, ONTARIO ~~~~~  March 18, 2021  (LSN)  The COVID-19 crisis has brought back to the forefront the idea of a universal basic income or guaranteed annual income. It’s an idea that should be abandoned.

In response to the economic crisis caused by the COVID-19 restrictions, the Canadian government has implemented the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB). Eligible people receive $2,000 for a four-week period (equivalent to $500 a week).

In March 2020, this system’s initial goal was to compensate those who couldn’t work for reasons related to COVID-19. The COVID-19 restrictions were extended and so was the CERB, which was later replaced by Employment Insurance (EI).

Giving money to people to compensate for the fact that they don’t work is pretty close to the idea of a universal basic income.

When we see that Canada is not the only country to use a CERB-like system, it’s easy to understand why universal basic income is becoming a trending topic around the world. The problem is that this system has been tested and failed to achieve its objectives.

Universal basic income could be described as a system where everyone would be entitled to a monthly subsidy of a few hundred dollars, regardless of their status or income. With fewer economic constraints, the poorest would be able to meet their basic needs.

The proponents of this concept think it will help fight unemployment and sustain people while they invest in education to improve their skills and get well-paying jobs.


FROM THE ARCHIVES: A guaranteed annual income is complicated by Pat Murphy


The problem is that someone will have to pay for this system. Even if the state gives everyone an income, people who work will be taxed with an amount greater than what they would receive with universal basic income.

Moreover, the system’s alleged positive effects remain to be proven, especially given the Finnish experiment’s failure.

The Finns implemented a universal basic income with 2,000 people, aged 25 to 58, who were receiving unemployment benefits. They were selected through random sampling without regional or other bias. They received a basic income of €560 (C$860) per month from 2017 to 2018.

The results showed that basic income doesn’t affect unemployment: people who received basic income proved to have the same level of unemployment as they would with a classic unemployment benefit.

The two-year experiment was deemed a failure by Finnish leaders. Nordic European countries are pragmatists and can acknowledge when a measure doesn’t work.

Besides its failure to reduce unemployment, a universal basic income presents some political problems. One is citizens’ dependency on the government and the state.

As Laurent Pahpy of the Paris-based Institute for Research in Economic and Fiscal Issues states: “The political excesses of such a system will not be long in coming: an electoral increase in the amount of universal income, the introduction of progressivity, financing by the printing press or the debt (thus by future generations).”

Moreover, funding a universal basic income would be costly. As the Fraser Institute notes, it would lead to significant tax increases.

Presented as a tool for a fairer and more equal society, universal basic income could instead lead to more divisions between workers who would be highly taxed and the people who would benefit the most from this new income.

Instead of giving ‘free’ money to everyone, a better solution to resolve the crisis and help people would be to reduce the governmental burden on the economy.

Forced solidarity with a universal income risks lowering entrepreneurial investment in the economy and jeopardizes wealth creation.

Fewer taxes and subsidies would help with the development and reopening of the country. Too many taxes and too much government interventionism would slow the return to prosperity.

Alexandre Massaux is a research associate with the Frontier Centre for Public Policy.

Alexandre is one of our Thought Leaders


 Troy Media

Universal basic income has been tested and failed added by  on 
View all posts by Alexandre Massaux →

Alexandre Massaux

Alexandre Massaux

Alexandre Massaux holds a PhD in Law from the University of Toulon in France. He also holds a master’s degree in Business Administration. He also collaborates with various think tanks like IREF Europe and the web magazine Contrepoints by commenting on and analyzing international current events. He was a research scholar at the CEVRO Institute in Prague in 2018. His main areas of interest are international relations, trade, and governance.

Northern Ontario 
Kenora, Rainy River, Dryden, Thunder Bay, Terrace Bay Marathon, Sault Ste Marie, Sudbury, North Bay, Ontario

#LSN_TBay  #LSN_SSM  #LSN_Econ 

© Troy Media

Disclaimer
The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by Lake Superior News / Lake Superior Media.

Troy Media Founded in 2005, Troy Media has grown to become Canada’s largest independent provider of original editorial features, opinions and analysis. Content sourced from Troy Media appears in dozens of newspapers, news sites, blogs and radio reports daily. Annual readership is estimated to be greater than 750 million.

 

Print

LSN Coverage Areas

Text/HTML


Lake Superior Shipwreck Map - Historically accurate shipwreck posters, of Lake Superior,
24 x 30 inches, shipped rolled in a tube.
$21.95 USD Plus $15.00 USD Shipping 

 

Follow LSN on Twitter

Social Media

 Twitter Lake Superior New  Face Book Lake Superior News  Lake Superior Circle Tour Calendar  You Tube Lake Superior News

Latest News

No content

A problem occurred while loading content.

Previous Next

GoGreen

Text/HTML

Shipwreck Maps

Great Lakes Shipwreck Maps Historically accurate, 29"x23" shipwreck posters are available for all five

Text/HTML


Lake Superior Shipwreck Map - Historically accurate shipwreck posters, of Lake Superior,
24 x 30 inches, shipped rolled in a tube.
$21.95 USD Plus $15.00 USD Shipping 

 

Text/HTML

Lake Superior News
Grand Portage Minnesota

Lake Superior News

Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan, Northern Ontario
 

Send Media Releases to:
News@LakeSuperiornews.com

Text/HTML

Lake Superior News

Thunder Bay, Ontario
 

News@LakeSuperiornews.com

 

    You Tube Lake Superior News   Twitter Lake Superior New  Face Book Lake Superior News

Text/HTML

Website Powered by DNN 4 Less

Copyright 2007 ~ 2021 Lake Superior Media.
Back To Top