Search User Login Menu
Tools
Close
Close

News Headlines

Lake Superior News Headlines 2019 Region. Thunder Bay, Duluth, Marquette, Houghton, Keweenaw peninsula, Upper Michigan, Sault Ste Marie, Cook Country, Minnesota

Latest News Headlines

Don’t be fooled by ShutDownCanada

Don’t be fooled by ShutDownCanada

misleading claims from dishonest activists

CALGARY, ALBERTA,   - February 21, 2020  (LSN) ——  On Tuesday, while activists reportedly tried to “arrest” Premier John Horgan at his house in British Columbia, Prime Minister Trudeau spoke to the House of Commons, stressing the need for “patience” as rail blockades continue to prevent freight and passenger across Canada.

Indeed, the #ShutDownCanada movement is in full swing in B.C. and across the country, with rail blockades, road closures and protests causing mass disruption and frustration. All because of the proposed Coastal GasLink pipeline through the traditional territory of the Wet’suwet’en First Nations people in B.C.

There’s been a lot said and written over the past week. But here’s what you need to know about this dispute.

According to the 1997 the Supreme Court of Canada Delgamuukw decision, the Wet’suwet’en have aboriginal title to an as-yet-undefined area of B.C. Aboriginal title is a form of ownership, but it’s not absolute. The same Supreme Court decision that recognized aboriginal title also elaborated the doctrine of infringement, which allows government to make use of title land for the public good.

This is one of those cases. The Coastal GasLink pipeline cannot be built without crossing Wet’suwet’en traditional territory. It will carry natural gas from B.C. fields to Kitimat, a municipality in the North Coast region of the province, where it will be liquified and exported to Asian markets. It’s an enormous project that will create profit for investors, revenue for governments (including First Nation governments) and jobs for workers, many of whom will be First Nations people. It will also reduce carbon emissions in the world at large because it will replace coal now burned for power generation in countries such as Japan, China and Korea.

The protestors talk about Wet’suwet’en sovereignty and Wet’suwet’en law, but don’t be misled. Canadian courts have consistently upheld Canadian sovereignty, which means that Parliament and the B.C. legislature have the right make law for the Wet’suwet’en. Traditional Wet’suwet’en laws are enforceable only if explicitly adopted through federal or B.C. legislation, depending on the subject matter. That has not happened. So traditional Wet’suwet’en law cannot be used to block pipeline construction.

In fact, Coastal GasLink passes through the traditional territories of 20 First Nations. The elected band councils of all these First Nations (including the Wet’suwet’en) signed agreements in support of the pipeline because of the substantial benefits they will receive—cash payments from the B.C. government and TC Energy, a natural gas company, not to mention jobs and job-training and contract set-asides for work on the pipeline.

These First Nations are small, poor and remote. They don’t have many economic opportunities. The average income of their members is about half the provincial average. Coastal GasLink is their best—perhaps only—way out of poverty. That’s why their elected governments have endorsed the pipeline.

So where’s the opposition coming from? A faction of the Wet’suwet’en, the hereditary chiefs who claim that only they—not the elected band council—can give consent to the pipeline. Again, don’t be misled. There is no basis in the Canadian Constitution, legislation or judicial decisions for this claim.

Many of the protestors swarming the B.C. legislature or blocking highways and railways across the country are not members of the Wet’suwet’en Nation or any other First Nation. They are the usual crowd of environmentalists and anti-capitalists. For many, their goal is to destroy the market economy that’s created so much prosperity and the democratic government that protects our freedoms. They want a government of activists, where they will call the shots. Their hashtag says it all—#ShutDownCanada.

Don’t be fooled. This isn’t a genuine movement for social justice. These are outsiders exploiting a division within one First Nation in the hope of creating chaos on the ground.

Canada is a free country. If the protestors stay within legal limits, let them speak. If they break the law by obstructing buildings, roads and railways, let the police do their job of re-establishing the civil order on which we all depend.

Author:

Tom Flanagan

Professor Emeritus of Political Science and Distinguished Fellow, School of Public Policy, University of Calgary

-30-


 

 

 

Fraser Institure  Lake Superior NewsThe Fraser Institute
 

https://www.fraserinstitute.org

 

Disclaimer
The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by Lake Superior News / Lake Superior Media.

 

Print

Minnesota News

123457910Last

Razor Host

Ontario News

Chippewa Park to Close

Chippewa Park to Close

COVID_19 as FWFN Locks Down

THUNDER BAY, ONTAIRO ~~  April 9, 2020  (LSN)  In response to Fort William First Nation’s decision to close all...
COVID-19 Around Lake Superior April 9th

COVID-19 Around Lake Superior April 9th

Number of Case and Locations by Community

THUNDER BAY, ONTARIO ~ April 9, 2020 (LSN)  Case of COVID-19 around Lake Superior Starting at the Ontario Manitoba border and east to...
123578910Last

Wisconsin Michigan News

New Life for an Old Ore Dock

New Life for an Old Ore Dock

Marquette organization's endeavor to repurpose the deactivated Lower Harbor Ore Dock

#LSN_Outdoors #LSN_MichNews MARQUETTE, MICHIGAN November 9, 2019   (LSN)  Students and faculty, Northern Michigan...

Follow LSN on Twitter

Latest News

No content

A problem occurred while loading content.

Previous Next

GoGreen

Back To Top